Why Santa only brings one gift

You may think it is crazy, but my children only get one present from Santa each year.

Why Santa only brings one gift

You may think it is crazy, but my children only get one present from Santa each year.
  • When I was writing for an Arizona newspaper, my paths crossed with a family life coach named Keri Maughan for a few articles, and I was always amazed by her wisdom and techniques. However, one thing she said floored me … "My children only get ONE gift from Santa at Christmas time." I was shocked! Was she the Grinch? Who has every heard of Santa only bringing ONE gift?

  • Then I sat back and listened to her reasoning:

  • 1. Santa brings what is most wanted

  • It can been big, small, expensive or cheap but he brings the item the child is most hoping for. No worries about "fairness" or the money spent per child. If you get the item you are most hoping for, all is fair.

  • 2. This idea cuts down on all the filler gifts that are immediately discarded once the "real" gift is opened.

  • This saves both money, time, and most importantly focus.

  • 3. If Santa brings only one gift, the child stops to take in the gift and then spends time playing with and enjoying it instead of wondering what else is under the tree.

  • 4. When other gifts are given from parents/siblings/grandparents, the child has a chance to show gratitude instead just look for more or "the next gift."

  • It is easy to show excitement and gratitude for a few great items as opposed to a million mediocre ones. Much less entitlement on Christmas morning.

  • 5. It allows for Christmas magic regardless of the families' financial situation

  • It all sounded really great to me. So, for the past 8 years, Santa has (mostly) brought our kids one big gift and then a book, a DVD, and some simple stocking stuffers. The rest of the items carry tags "From: Mom and Dad" or "Love: Grandma and Grandpa."

  • We still get all the Christmas magic we are hoping for and our kids don't set unrealistic or incredibly greedy expectations or create mile long lists for the jolly man in the big red suit.

  • They understand that with mom and dad there is a finite amount of money spent each year … some years are fatter and some years are leaner, but we always have incredible Christmases.

  • I cannot tell you how grateful I was that we had started this tradition when we went back to grad school with three kids. I knew Christmas would be slim and we were an entire country away from extended family. However, both Christmases were still wonderful occasions and Santa came through with one great gift while the rest of the items were second hand, from grandparents, or found at incredible deals.

  • Advertisement
  • Even still, our little apartment was warm and cozy with plenty of love and still too many gifts to even wrap our minds around. It's astounding that it still always seemed like too much.

  • At this time of year, I am especially grateful to be able to provide Christmas for our family. I know it is a luxury many don't have, so reach out and make sure each child has at least ONE present from Santa this year by visiting your local Angel Tree or contacting your church or city about families in need.

  • Editor's note: This article was originally published on Brooke Romney Writes. It has been republished here with permission.

Brooke Romney is the author of Brooke Romney Writes, where she shares favorite travel destinations, great books, parenting ideas, food to eat and food for thought. She has a weakness for fall, sunshine, date night, nature, good reads, adventure, gummy candy and all things boy. After living in 5 states and 9 different cities, she now resides with her husband and 4 little men in Utah.


Tell us your opinion

Have More Meaningful Conversations With Your Kids.

We’ll send the low-down on the hot topics your kids are talking about to your inbox every morning so you’re ready to talk with them.


Enter a valid email address (e.g. [email protected])

Thanks for subscribing to our email list. Please enjoy our latest articles.